Rear Vs. Wing-Mounted Aircraft Engines


Commercial airliners are generally known for their under-the-wing engine design. Unlike regional jets such as the Embraer ERJs and Bombardier CRJs, most single-aisle and widebody commercial jets have under-the-wing engines. On the other hand, rear-mounted engines are still quite common in private aviation. Most corporate jets feature two engines fitted on the rear fuselage. Some Dassault aircraft, such as the Falcon 900, comprise three rear-mounted engines. Aircraft designs are purely based on their mission requirements and driven by constraints. Both designs have their positive and negative attributes. Let’s take a more detailed look at both.

There’s no doubt that aircraft with rear-mounted engines have cleaner wings. Because the engines aren’t attached to the wings, engineers have more freedom when designing the wings and are free to build a much more efficient structure. Placing engines under the wings breaks up its smooth shape, which reduces the total lifting surface and causes a minor loss of lift. Complex leading-edge and sometimes trailing-edge flaps are required to recover this lift. Rear-mounted engines solve these issues. It’s also easier to control the aircraft in the event of an engine failure. The rear-mounted engines are closer to the center of gravity than their wing-mounted cousins. Hence, when an engine fails, the yaw (the side to side rotation of the nose) generated by the live engine is significantly reduced, requiring less pilot effort to control.

Rear-mounted engines allow the aircraft to sit low to the ground. As the engines are not close, the landing gear can be shorter, reducing the design complexity. Because the airplane fuselage is close to the ground, the aircraft may not require equipment such as high loaders to load baggage and cargo. In addition to this, the aircraft can be fitted with a simple air stair to board passengers. As engines are rear-mounted, away from the passenger cabin, engine noise and vibration is also making it more comfortable for the passengers. The T-tail design makes the elevator controls more effective. A T-tail means that the tail and the elevator can be placed farther away from the center of gravity. This gives the pilots better leverage and more pitch control, lowering their take-off and landing speeds.

Notwithstanding the positives, T-tails are susceptible to a dangerous phenomenon known as a deep stall. In this situation, a strong wake from the wing may cover the T-tail, rendering it ineffective, meaning pilots can no longer push the nose down to recover from the stall. Rear-mounted engines also require a more complex fuel system since fuel must be pumped upwards above the fuel tanks, which calls for stronger fuel pumps. And, standby pumps are also needed for redundancy purposes, thereby increasing costs. The engines also take away baggage or cargo space: This point is specific to corporate jets as most of these aircraft have such space behind the cabin. So, having engines at the rear reduces the space available for bags or cargo and the engines can also make it difficult to load such items. Despite these shortcomings, rear-mounted engines remain popular on corporate and private jets because they provide cleaner wing aerodynamics, superior cabin quietness, and safer ground operations despite structural weight penalties.

In the world of commercial aviation, wing-mounted engines are widespread. Wing-mounted engines reduce wing bending moments. In flight, the wings generate massive upward lift, trying to fold upward at the root (where the wing meets the fuselage). The heavy engines mounted on the wings help to counteract this and pull them downward. This downward force opposes the lift, acting as a structural relief valve. Because the engines counteract some of the upward force, the net bending stress at the wing root is significantly reduced. This actually makes the dramatic wing flex of the Boeing 787 possible and safe. It might seem contradictory, but because the wing-mounted engines relieve structural stress at the root, Boeing engineers didn’t have to make the inner wing excessively thick, rigid, or heavy to withstand the lift forces. Instead, they were able to construct a lighter, higher-aspect-ratio wing using advanced carbon-fiber composites. The 787's iconic upward flex during flight is a safe, calculated aerodynamic feature that absorbs turbulence and reduces drag, made structurally feasible by the weight relief of the engines.

Jet fuel is primarily stored inside the wings. Placing engines directly underneath allows shorter, more direct fuel lines and enables gravity-fed fuel transfer should the fuel pumps fail. Wing mounted engines hang away from the main fuselage, letting them swallow smooth, undisturbed air that boosts propulsive efficiency. In addition, the engine intake is away from the aircraft structure, therefore the engines can take in clean, undisturbed air. They are also much easier to maintain. Engines mounted low and under the wings give ground crews direct, fast access for routine inspections, oil changes, and minor repairs without requiring tall ladders or specialized lifts. Moving the engines away from the passenger cabin frees up valuable fuselage space for more seats as well as cargo. Modern high-bypass turbofan engines have also grown too large and heavy to safely mount on an aircraft's tail. However, the aircraft with engines mounted on the wings require longer landing gear to ensure sufficient ground clearance and they are more susceptible to Foreign Object Damage (FOD) from ground debris. That’s why commercial runways are visually swept for debris and why airports conduct rigorous visual inspections and use specialized sweeping vehicles on a daily basis to ensure the tarmac is clear.

Two aircraft stand out for combining both rear and wing-mounted engines. The McDonnell Douglas DC-10 and the Lockheed L-1011 TriStar occupy a unique place in aviation history. They combined two under-wing engines with a single, highly specialized rear-mounted engine integrated along the tail centerline. While I have fond memories of flying aboard both aircraft types, the commercial aviation industry moved away from this layout due to a combination of regulatory updates, exploding maintenance and fuel costs, and advancements in engine technology. When the DC-10 and L-1011 were designed in the late 1960s, jet engines were prone to failure and the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) enforced a strict 60-minute rule. This rule banned twin-engine airplanes from flying routes that took them more than 60 minutes away from an emergency diversion airport, ruling out transatlantic and transpacific flights. Because three-engine aircraft were exempt from this 54rule, trijets became the perfect middle ground. They were more fuel-efficient than a four-engine giant like the Boeing 747, yet legally allowed to cross oceans. By the 1980s and 1990s though engine technology had evolved and the industry switched to highly powerful and reliable high-bypass turbofan engines like those seen on the Boeing 767. Regulators then introduced ETOPS (Extended-range Twin-engine Operational Performance Standards), which allowed twin-engine planes to fly long-distance overwater routes. Once twins could fly the same routes, the fundamental legal reason for building trijets vanished.
There are pros and cons to both. We’ve seen that rear-mounted engines are common on business jets because they keep the wing clean and allow shorter landing gear while wing-mounted engines dominate large commercial airliners due to structural bending relief and easier maintenance.
Until next time…safe travels.
Until next time...safe travels.



Comments